
AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.
- calendar_today November 17, 2026
Federal Judge Schedules Four-Day Hearing for Channen Smith’s Innocence Claim
Channen Smith, an Oklahoma prisoner serving a life sentence for first-degree murder, is set to have his actual innocence claim reviewed during a rare four-day evidentiary hearing in federal court. The hearing, initially scheduled for November 9, was postponed to March 2027 due to a death in one of the attorneys’ families.
Background: The 2010 Shooting and Conviction
Smith was convicted in 2013 by a Tulsa County jury for the shooting of Carlameisha Jefferson and Dominique Jasper outside a home in north Tulsa on October 23, 2010. Prosecutors contended that Smith was motivated by a previous argument and a romantic dispute, leading him to open fire. Jefferson survived her injuries, but Jasper died 23 days after the incident. Smith received a life sentence for murder, along with additional sentences for related charges including shooting with intent to kill and being a felon in possession of a firearm.
Federal Appeal and the Gateway Actual Innocence Claim
Over a decade later, Smith filed a pro se federal habeas corpus petition, persisting with his wrongful conviction claim despite the procedural barriers. In April 2025, U.S. District Judge Sara Hill found that Smith had presented a credible gateway actual innocence claim, ordering the state to respond. Hill wrote, “A reasonable juror confronted with the newly supplemented record more likely than not would have reasonable doubt about Smith’s guilt.”
Key Evidence: Third-Party Confession and Witness Testimony
Central to Smith’s innocence claim is a confession allegedly made by Arlan Young, who reportedly admitted to the shootings before his death from cancer in 2017. Two of Young’s cousins, Tomique Thomas and Tiffani Carroll, submitted affidavits supporting this confession and will testify as witnesses. Smith’s legal team, led by Smolen and Associates since July 2025, also cited claims of prosecutorial misconduct and ineffective assistance of counsel.
The state, represented by the Oklahoma Attorney General’s Office, disputes the confession's credibility. Investigations after Judge Hill’s order concluded Young’s account was implausible. The state continues to emphasize testimony from Jasper’s mother, who recounted that her son had identified Smith as the shooter, and from Brandon Savage, who stated that Smith confessed in jail. Prosecutors also argue that Smith and his supporters fabricated the story implicating Young, citing medical records suggesting Young was too ill to leave his home at the time he allegedly confessed to Thomas.
Arguments and Next Steps in Smith’s Legal Fight
The state maintains the evidence against Smith remains strong and has requested that Hill deny relief, accusing Smith’s advocates of submitting false testimony. Smith’s supporters dispute these allegations. Jennifer West, a law student and advocate for Smith, described the state’s theory as far-fetched, pointing out the lack of physical evidence and questioning why Young’s cousins would invent a confession.
Following the evidentiary hearing, Judge Hill could rule on Smith’s petition. Even if granted, such decisions may lead either to a retrial or a resentencing rather than immediate release, as per the U.S. Department of Justice guidelines for habeas corpus cases.
Other Recent Developments in Oklahoma Innocence Claims
Smith’s case comes amid other significant legal updates involving Oklahoma prisoners maintaining their innocence. Richard Glossip, previously on death row, recently pleaded guilty to a reduced charge after his conviction was vacated by the U.S. Supreme Court due to prosecutorial misconduct. Meanwhile, Joshua Christon was released from prison this month after his sentence was modified, having argued that prosecutors misused his rap lyrics to secure his conviction.
Related coverage
Source: oklahomawatch.org.




